Case Study: Unwinding Ritual Cycles in Final Fantasy X

A version of this essay has in the past been given as a talk called ‘Spheres, Cycles, Circles, and Spira,’ originally for the IGDA Foundation.

This essay also contains spoilers for Final Fantasy X.

—

Released in 2001 by Square (pre-Enix!), Final Fantasy X is a turn-based RPG that follows a young man ripped from his time by a monster attack and launched one thousand years into a bleak future. In this future his Zanarkand is but a ruin, and the land of Spira is being continually ravaged by the same monster who dragged him there: Sin. With little else to do, Tidus joins the pilgrimage of Summoner Yuna and, with his fellow Guardians, begins the trek from temple to temple with the goal of borrowing the power of creatures called Aeons to eventually defeat Sin. At least, temporarily.

You see, the world of FFX operates in nested cycles. There is the cycle of Sin: Rebirth, rampage, defeat, and ten years of Calm. Triggered by the rampage, there is also the cyclic pilgrimage of the Summoners: Arrival at a temple, trials, prayer, departure. These two dance like interlocked gears until the smaller machinations of the Summoner complete a revolution around the giant cog of Sin, both die, and start anew. In the story world, this is simply unquestionable, a law like gravity.

I find FFX a particularly effective piece of work because of the way its in-world rituals (the narrative rituals performed by in-world actors) interact with the player’s metarituals (gameplay rituals not necessarily related to story progression, performed by the player in menus). A ritual by definition is a rigid, formal, and repeatable predefined sequence that carries symbolism and meaning within a larger system, and contains elements that lack direct instrumental purpose (Hobson, Schroeder et al., 2018).

(I, admittedly, teetered on the edge of citing some of the studies I read in the body of this paper. I landed on including them because I think they’re broadly useful in pointing out how keenly the devs observed the purpose and nature of ritual in the real world and were able to reflect them in this narrative.)

Playing the Game

Turn-based RPGs attract a very specific audience of, affectionately speaking, sickos. Even the lowest-difficulty progression in such a game requires at least a tolerance for complex menus and basic systems knowledge; the higher-level difficulty settings require advanced planning in the management of stats, inventory, and the cadence of combat. Interacting with this type of game design inherently benefits from a more structured approach to a play session.

That being said, using the Hobson and Schroeder definition in the context of this essay does imply that a player has to have some level of buy-in or immersion in the story as well as some fluency in turn-based RPG mechanics in order for the play to be considered ritual rather than routine. Engaging in the rigid, formal, and pre-defined sequence of playing the game only requires playing it as-designed, the play lacks a direct instrumental purpose in the sense that our button press is not actually an attack on a creature or the casting of a spell, but in order for these actions to mean something within the larger system (the story, which only affects us in proportion to our investment in it), we must allow ourselves to suspend disbelief and engage earnestly with the material. Additionally, a new player who finds themselves constantly referring to guides or other resources may have a harder time engaging with the story if the bulk of their attention is spent on understanding mechanics.

But, in earnest and fluent engagement, we can find metarituals. FFX is a game released originally on the PlayStation 2 — can you hear the startup noise in your head? (If you can, how are your knees?) This noise peels back the first layer of reality in the same way that the dimming of the lights in a theater does. The menu and its mysterious music slough off the next layer.

For me, the most ritualized part of gameplay is the wind-down at the end of every session. I find inventory and character management to be a nurturing meditation. I am able to buy into a story enough that, in many cases, I concern myself with the stats of a piece of equipment only slightly more than the likelihood of a character wanting to use that kind of item. I attach emotional significance to certain pieces of equipment all the time — any RPG that allows me to have some kind of home base storage container will see that container filled with objects that are functionally useless but at one time meaningful within the text.

So, when I am ready to finish up or find myself at a hub world, my (rigid and repeatable process) is as follows:

  1. Inventory: I usually try to stop my play in a hub world so I can sell what I don’t need, restock consumables, and check for equipment.
  2. Equipment: Did I pick up anything stronger than what a character is currently wearing, either adventuring or shopping? Do I need to make any swaps?
  3. Leveling: I usually tackle characters in order of how frequently I use them in a party.
  4. Planning: I check any quest logs or mail, and tell myself what I’ll do next time I play.

Then I save twice. Exit the game. Shut down the console. When I return, the cycle will begin anew.

The way in which we interact with games and take certain conventions for granted are critical components in game design and I personally like when they get subverted or taken advatage of in some way: Bioshock, Spec Ops: The Line, Inscryption, Doki Doki Literature Club, Transistor, Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons, Titanium Court — to do this well is to be in good company. A successful execution of this moment takes all the suspension of disbelief and the abstraction built by the game and the format in which its played and rips out from under the player, sending them crashing back into their own body and awareness.

FFX distinguishes itself here in two ways: One, its subversion of convention is not made entirely obvious to the player; two, this subversion is not built to make the player feel somehow bad or complicit in the events of the narrative. If anything, it’s built to make the player feel as hopeful and triumphant as the characters surely do when they do eventually dismantle Sin for good.

An Honorable Mention for the Sphere Grid 

The Sphere Grid is the leveling mechanism in FFX; a large node-based map where each character starts in a circular maze and winds outwards, choosing abilities as they level. I really like this layout as a matter of visuals, but I particularly love the narrative implications that it has in the higher levels, as characters begin to intrude on each other’s spaces. One could easily take the read that this group of people who has been traveling together for a long time now and has grown closer, is teaching one another.

Yevon, A Natural Facsimile

A game in which a character linearly fulfills a series of increasingly complex ritualized tasks in order to take down a god-monster, even if that ultimately means the character perishes along with its quarry, would have plenty of room for story interest and be a completely acceptable 30-hour experience. FFX, however, is not about completing the ritual, but about unraveling it.

Yevon as an in-game religion stands out as one of the most tactile, impactful, and easy-to-understand deployments of fictional religion in games. This is in part because the game uses rituals in a way that is concomitant with real world use cases. Ritual practices can make a person feel more in-control (Yin, et al., 2022), and people tend to return to prayer and rituals during crisis periods (Bentzen, 2021). Rituals can also focus an individual’s attention away from negative stimulus, galvanize a group against an outside threat, prescribe additional meaning to outcomes that may not be at all dependent on the completion of the ritual, and dictate the norms used to communicate with a member of the in-group during an interaction (Hobson and Schroeder et al., 2018).

The nature of Yuna’s pilgrimage is obvious to all of her guardians, and is further propelled by the fact that her father was the Summoner who successfully completed the cycle before her. The weight of the expectations of the people of Spira drive her to be studious and self-sacrificing on her journey. Let’s take a moment here to expand a little on the nature of the Summoners’ quest.

  1. Arrival at a temple: The Summoners travel from one temple of Yevon to another. Their arrival within a Temple is marked, to the player, by the sound of the Hymn of the Fayth.
  2. Trials: The Summoner enters the Cloister of Trials and proceeds through a series of puzzles in order to access the Fayth.
  3. Prayer: The Summoner prays to the Fayth, a statue wherein an ancient soul is bound and awaits a Summoner’s call in order to be mobilized against Sin as an Aeon — a creature who does battle alongside the Summoner.
  4. Departure: Once the Aeon has been claimed, the Summoner moves on to the next Temple.

I’m a person who has a lot of trouble engaging with fictional religion because it often feels like doing homework that has little actionable effect on the narrative; a god in the context of an RPG is often just some guy (gender neutral) who makes a lot of threats, but you can absolutely beat using normal mechanics. In FFX, god is inertia, and the true nature of this inertia is exposed through friction.

Friction Point: Companions

A very common way to introduce a player to a narrative adventure is to have them pilot a character that is somehow also new to the world or situation. Tidus is not only genuinely confused, as he was ripped one thousand years into the future, but he is immediately told to mask the truth of his arrival by saying he was, functionally, bonked on the head. He is also kind of a dummy, which helps.

Many RPGs launch an unknowing character into a new situation so that they can ask the same questions a player would, but not all treat that character as an outsider for asking. Tidus has a vested interest in keeping his mouth shut around anyone outside his immediate pilgrimage group (though he rarely does so), but he’s not truly without information. He just doesn’t see its relevance: When he notices that the Yevonite bow is the same as the one he used as a professional athlete in ancient Zanarkand, he doesn’t point out the similarity. And in this observation we get the first hint that something is amiss.

Tidus’ observation of the Sending in Kilika — a funerary ritual performed by Summoners after a mass casualty event — is similarly revealing. In this scene, Yuna walks on the water and performs a spinning, circular dance over the wrapped bodies of the victims. In rituals with a physical component, such as a dance, the motion often mimics the mood of the intent (Hobson and Schroeder et al., 2018). It is notable then, that Yuna’s dance here is largely composed of spins; she is physically perpetuating the cycle Spira is trapped in. While everyone around her emphasizes her duty to do this, it is only Tidus that remarks on how sad she looks during her performance. His point of view rips us out of the cycle for a scant moment.

Video: SquareEnix // The song playing in the background here is the Hymn of the Fayth. Yevon describes it as a song to soothe the souls of the dead.

Tidus is a stranger to these circumstances, but this Guardian group has another functional outsider in an opposite position: Auron, who accompanied Yuna’s father and is now taking the pilgrimage again.

Let’s think about this specifically in the context of the Sin/Summoner ritual cycles: They require buy-in from their participants in order to generate the feeling of inertia — real inertia, after all, does not require maintenance. Unless there is active resistance.

Tidus has no buy-in, and Auron knows too much. Auron ensures that Tidus doesn’t develop buy-in to Spira’s ritual cycles by revealing that, somehow, his dead father is now Sin. Both of these men, along with Yuna’s cousin Rikku who is from a culture that does not follow Yevon’s doctrine, are anchors dragging Yuna out of the cycle.

Which raises the question: What is keeping us in?

Part of the meaning derived from ritual practices lies in the fact that they often come from long ancestral traditions, and are seen as unchanged over time (Hobson and Schroeder et al., 2018). In the story of Yevon, Sin appeared in order to punish the people of Spira for their interaction with advanced technology (Machina) and will continue to appear until the people of Spira have fully repented for the actions of their ancestors. As part of this quest, Yevon has banned all Machina, and thus, modernization.

This is why the Yevonites resent the Al Bhed, a functionally second-class desert culture that engages with the Machina freely and seemingly with little to no consequence. This means that the Al Bhed must operate insularly, under threat of violence and persecution from Yevon. This problem is forefronted by the fact that one of the Guardians on Yuna’s journey (and one of Tidus’ closest co-conspirators) is Rikku, Yuna’s Al Bhed cousin. Like Tidus, Rikku has to keep her Al Bhed heritage close to her chest as at least one companion would think of her as a heretic if he knew; unlike Tidus, she knows enough about the modern world to point out its absurdities often and loudly.

Weights and Counterbalances

Another thing about the ritual cycles in FFX is that they require death. The death of Sin, however temporary, as well as the death of the successful Summoner, and the deaths of countless innocents. Again, I think it would be perfectly acceptable for a fantasy adventure game to say that Yuna’s friends convinced her of the absurdity of her task and they all found a way to beat Sin together using the power of love and friendship. That is not what happens in this narrative. Part of the great unraveling of these cycles throughout the course of the game is not only caused by the way Tidus, Rikku, and Auron try to drag it to a stop from the outside, but also by the corruption of the chief living architects of this scheme.

This concept of corruption through stagnancy is introduced at base level with the Fiends, the monstrous remnants of undead souls who make up the bulk of the game’s encounters. When it comes to named characters, we see multiple phases of this corruption play out simultaneously:

Maester Seymour becomes unsent in front of us, and as a direct result of our actions in combat. A young Maester, he is ambitious and plans to allow Sin to rampage as he believes that death is the only salvation for Spira. When Yuna and the team take him down, he refuses to go, and becomes increasingly monstrous in the process.

Maester Mika, the leader of all the peoples of Spira who has been Maester for fifty years is also revealed to be unsent. His unwillingness to surrender his power and the issue of Sin corrupts him irreparably.

The Summoner’s quest ends in the ruins of Zanarkand, where they are to find the first successful Summoner to have defeated Sin: Yunalesca. We have already mentioned that rituals get their legitimacy from the sense that they are ancient and unchanged — this inertia is what prevents anyone from Spira to raise the question: Why is Yunalesca still around, then? Yunalesca, as part of this ritual, somehow escapes the label of ‘unsent’, even though that’s what she is.

The only person who is aware of Yunalesca’s status is Auron, who has been through this before. When Yunalesca reveals that the vaunted Final Summoning is not based on prayer to some powerful Fayth but in the sacrifice of a living, meaningful companion of the Summoner’s, he reveals his purpose in wanting to finally stop this madness. This is also how we learn about Tidus’ father becoming Sin: He volunteered to be sacrificed by Yuna’s father, during their successful pilgrimage.

The other critical usent is revealed to be Yu Yevon, the founder of the religion, the creator of the Fayth, and the final boss of the game. He is no longer human when confronted: He appears as monstrous as any Fiend, reduced to a small, floating, bug-like entity. He is so corrupted and unwilling to pass on responsibilities to the next generation, in fact, that he is the thing perpetuating the cycle of Sin.

This is another fantastic anchor dragging the party out of the ritual cycle. Jecht is still semi-conscious inside Sin, acting as Yu Yevon’s Aeon. This creature is now semi-cooperative in its own destruction, carried only by the rot of Yu Yevon in its core. And, Jecht is more likely to remember some of his humanity if he can hear his favorite tune: the Hymn of the Fayth.

The Hymn plays at every temple — a signal to the player that the Summoner ritual cycle is about to begin — and marks other key moments in the game. The story as told by Yevonites is that it is a song performed to soothe the souls of the dead. This is not true: It is a protest song from Zanarkand that was at first banned, and then reappropriated by Yevon.

Which — this interface will not let me put images within a textbox so please excuse me as I take a textual detour here — since we’re talking about reversals, we need to take a moment to talk about the musicality of the Hymn.

The Hymn of the Fayth is written like so:

Image: Musescore // If you don’t know musical notation, don’t worry about it. Just pay attention to the pattern of the notes.

If you’ve ever listened to any kind of classical music, you’re likely familiar with the Dies Irae, a four-note melody that signals death (for an explainer of the melody click here, for a detailed breakdown in the context of Disney’s Hunchback of Notre Dame, click here). It is written like so:

Image: mfiles

The Hymn of the Fayth is an inversion of the Dies Irae, which is to say: It is an inversion of the near-universal theme of death. It is a song of life. This makes it even more ironic that Yevon — a death cult! — has subsumed it and inverted its meaning once again.

Now that we’ve gotten more context than we know what to do with, let’s review our pieces on the board. The forces perpetuating the cycles are:

  • The inertia of the ritual practices in Spira, perpetuated by all its devotees.
  • Unsent in power: Yunalesca, as well as Maesters Seymour and Mika.
  • Yu Yevon, a long-unsent, no-longer-human remnant of the founder of the religion.

The forces dragging the cycles to a stop are:

  • Jecht, currently Yu Yevon’s Aeon and therefore Sin, who has retained his consciousness and wants the destruction to end.
  • Auron, who has seen a “successful” pilgrimage before and wants to save both of his dead friends’ children, and Rikku who sees Yevon as what it actually is.
  • Tidus, who is — well, he’s in love with Yuna, so uh …

… Wait, why is he here again? Why was Jecht here? If Tidus was pulled out of time by Sin, wouldn’t the same have happened to his father? So why doesn’t Tidus know of Sin? Why was Auron there when Sin attacked?

In true Producer fashion I will answer the question with a question: If Yunalesca was taken for granted as an unsent, what does that make the Fayth?

The things we are told about the Fayth are true: They are the long-gone people who allowed Yevon to seal their souls in stone in order to battle Sin. They are the core of this cycle and could easily be mistaken as having always been in opposition to Sin, when in fact their very function in fighting him in the prescribed way was perpetuating the death cycle ravaging Spira. They are the underappreciated force of inertia carrying this entire cycle, and they have no counterbalance — other than themselves.

The Fayth grew tired, and started to seek a way out.

Who has more right to be tired of this cycle than the Fayth? And what better way to comfort oneself than to dream of home? Which is to say — Tidus and Jecht are both artifacts of the Fayth’s collective dream of Zanarkand. They are not only not of this world, but explicitly born of an effort to birth a better one.

This is where the great undoing starts. This reveal is the reversal of the Final Summoning: Instead of Yuna dying and Tidus becoming the Final Aeon and therefore the next Sin, it will be Tidus who disappears when the Fayth stop dreaming and Yuna’s responsibility to usher forward the new world.

Next:

  • It is the devotees of Yevon who sing the Hymn of the Fayth to awaken Jecht inside Sin.
  • Yunalesca, Seymour, and Mika all move on to the Farplane — some willingly, some not.
  • And killing Yu Yevon requires the ritual destruction of every Aeon.

This final boss sequence is so profoundly well structured that it’s been stuck in my head for years. First, the big boss battle against Jecht as the Final Aeon, which allows Tidus to wrap out his narrative arc, and then the confrontation with Yu Yevon.

Now, I have a pet theory about why sequenced boss battles in JRPGs work so well. I think it’s because they hit the following narrative beats, generally speaking:

  1. Skill Ending: This is the big combat sequence where you really get to flex your skills and consumable/equipment hoarding.
  2. Cooldown: A slightly easier battle — sometimes a hoard of smaller enemies comes to turn down the tension before the game cranks it back up again.
  3. Cinematic Setup: A largely on-rails denouement that is guiding you towards one final, epic shot on the boss.
  4. Final Cutscene: You did it! Time to enjoy the end.

I think FFX’s final sequence maps well onto this theory:

  1. Skill Ending: This is the fight against Jecht, and the bow we can put on Tidus’ character arc.
  2. Cooldown: Yuna must summon every Aeon she collected, allow them to be posssessed by Yu Yevon in his insatiable and instinctual desire for continuing, and battle them in order to undo the summoning.
  3. Cinematic Setup: An on-rails confrontation with what remains of Yu Yevon.
  4. Final Cutscene: The final Sending!

Every single metaritual that the player has built up, along with every creature gathered as part of the narrative rituals, must now be undone as the battle goes on-rails and Sin possesses and unmakes each Aeon in turn.

And of course, there is one more (heavily-hinted and fairly obvious) reveal to contend with. As Yuna begins the final Sending of all the souls trapped inside Sin, her movements affect Auron — unsent. Unlike the others, Auron tells her to go on and allows himself to be sent. His mission is done and unlike the other unsent in the narrative, he is ready to pass on the responsibility of the new world to the next generation. This is the final unraveling.

A Narrative Solution

Let’s return to what this means for the player. At the moment I find myself attentive to places where design solves are implemented versus technical solves. Bioshock’s ‘Would you kindly,’ for example, is a design solve that retroactively changes the feeling of the player’s actions within the game. The way that Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons disables a joystick is a technical way to make the player feel an absence.

Final Fantasy X implements a couple of flourishes in the final sequence (allowing Tidus to talk to Jecht to calm him, and putting the battle against Yu Yevon on rails) but does not fundamentally alter the way in which turn-based gameplay is implemented. What the designers do is allow the change in the narrative to change the feeling of the battles.

The thing we as the players perpetuate by engaging in combat, for the bulk of playtime, is the inertial of the cycle of the Summoner. But once Yuna and her team break out of that cycle, that momentum has to be redirected — the new goal is not necessarily just to defeat Sin, but to stop these cycles wholesale and take Spira in a new direction. The mood of the narrative is different, the shackles of dread and inevitability (at least in terms of the larger narrative) have been dropped, and we are now racing towards something new.

Again: All of this requires buy-in from the audience. If you don’t find Tidus and Yuna’s story compelling then of course the combat will feel grinding and repetitive (and hey, the game is 25 years old — there’s some random encounter design flaws, I’m not saying it’s perfect). However, I think it’s fascinating to see what happens when a team trusts its narrative to carry the mechanics towards fulfillment, trusts that its audience is the kind that will generally buy in to fantasy shenanigans, and shows restraint in where it makes improvements or innovations to a formula.

Which is to say, ironically, I think this game is a triumph of the inertia of Square.

Image: Square, via Mobygames

Works Cited:

Bentzen, J. S. (2021). In crisis, we pray: Religiosity and the COVID-19 pandemic. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 192, 541–583. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jebo.2021.10.014

Hobson, N. M., Schroeder, J., Risen, J. L., Xygalatas, D., & Inzlicht, M. (2017). The Psychology of Rituals: An Integrative Review and Process-Based Framework. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 22(3), 260–284. https://doi.org/10.1177/1088868317734944

YIN Keli, LAN Miaosen, LI Hui, ZHAO Ziwen. (2022). How ritual actions, symbolic meanings, and positive emotions enhance perceived control: A dual path way mechanism. Acta Psychologica Sinica, 54(1), 54-65.


Discover more from Leyla Mamedova

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.